Elite Longevity Elite LongevitySustainable health and prevention Request a call
Podcast

Nutri-Score: Serge Hercberg answers the critics

A plant-based steak with no fat, no sugar and no salt can earn an excellent score even though it is packed with additives.

5 October 2026 · 9 min read

Serge Hercberg et Benjamin Sant au micro sur le plateau du podcast, avec une étiquette Nutri-Score notée E et le titre « Le Nutri-Score vous trompe ? »

By Benjamin Sant · Updated on 5 October 2026

By Benjamin Sant · Updated 5 October 2026

A plant-based steak with no fat, no sugar and no salt can earn an excellent score even though it is packed with additives. Conversely, a hundred per cent pure fruit grape juice, not industrially processed, contains so much sugar that it should be consumed with great moderation. This paradox is one Serge Hercberg knows better than anyone. A doctor by training, a former member of Médecins Sans Frontières, professor of nutrition and architect of the Nutri-Score, he addresses without flinching the real limits of his tool, the attacks it faces and the battle, still ongoing, to make it compulsory.

Watch the full episode on YouTube

The Nutri-Score was born out of a four-year political battle

The story begins in 2014, when health minister Marisol Touraine gave Serge Hercberg a mission to revive French nutrition policy. Among the fifteen measures proposed in his report is a five-colour logo, the fruit of several years of scientific work by his research team. The minister chose that measure rather than the other fourteen. But between the proposal and official adoption, it would take until 2017, four years of intense confrontation with industrial lobbies.

Serge Hercberg describes that period as trench warfare fought with disinformation. Opponents used methods directly inspired by the tobacco industry: discrediting the tool by calling it simplistic or stigmatising, funding pseudo-scientific studies to sow doubt, and pushing compliant MPs to table blocking amendments. Against that, the only weapon was the accumulation of scientific evidence and the mobilisation of consumer associations, which eventually convinced political leaders.

The fight for compulsion continues today

Adopted in 2017, the Nutri-Score remains voluntary. Today more than fifteen hundred brands display it voluntarily, but that covers only about sixty per cent of the food market. The major groups missing from the list have one thing in common: Ferrero, Lactalis, Coca-Cola, Mars, Mondelez and Unilever still refuse to display it, alongside the powerful agricultural unions for meat and cheese.

At European level, the Farm to Fork strategy nevertheless planned a compulsory, science-based logo by 2050. An OECD study estimated that generalising the Nutri-Score across the twenty-seven countries would reduce the number of chronic disease cases by two million. But according to Serge Hercberg, Giorgia Meloni’s Italy, very close to Ferrero and to charcuterie producers, derailed the project. In France, the vote was decided by three votes during the last social security financing law. A cross-party bill carried by around fifty MPs from nine different parties is now under discussion, accompanied by a citizens’ petition approaching the hundred thousand signatures needed to refer the matter to the social affairs committee.

The logo does not measure how food is processed

The strongest criticism addressed to the Nutri-Score concerns its inability to assess the degree of industrial processing. Serge Hercberg accepts it plainly, with two striking examples. A plant-based steak with no fat, sugar or salt but loaded with additives gets a good score even though it is an ultra-processed product. Conversely, a pure fruit grape juice is not processed, but its hundred and sixty grams of sugar per litre place it in an unfavourable category. These two dimensions, nutritional composition and degree of processing, cannot be merged into a single algorithm because they measure different realities, independent of each other.

The solution proposed by the research team is to surround the logo with a black border carrying the words ultra-processed food, following the NOVA classification developed by Brazilian researchers. Tested on twenty thousand people, that graphic approach works very well to inform about both dimensions at once. It comes up against, once again, the opposition of manufacturers. For pesticides, a logo already exists: the organic farming one.

One key figure often forgotten by critics should also be recalled: eighty-seven point five per cent of ultra-processed products are classified C, D or E by the Nutri-Score. The two notions therefore overlap widely, even if they are not identical.

Comparing salmon with olive oil makes no sense

The other recurring criticism concerns absurd comparisons, such as salmon rated lower than breakfast cereals, or olive oil long classified in category D. Serge Hercberg points out that olive oil is now classified B, the best possible score for a pure fat, the same as rapeseed oil. It does not get A simply because it is a product made of a hundred per cent lipids, which cannot be consumed in large quantities despite its recognised nutritional qualities.

The real problem, in his view, is that nobody chooses between a bottle of olive oil and a fizzy drink when doing the shopping. The relevance of the Nutri-Score appears when you compare products consumed in the same context: oils with each other, drinks with each other, breakfast cereals with each other. Within that logic of intra-category comparison, water remains the only drink classified A, ahead of fruit juices, themselves ahead of fizzy drinks. In the same way, thirty-five brands of crunchy chocolate muesli can display scores ranging from A to E for a product with the same name, a variability invisible without that visual marker.

Manufacturers can reformulate without losing money

Faced with a bad score, some manufacturers choose the virtuous route of reformulation: removing sugar, salt or fats, or cleaning up additives. One surimi manufacturer, for example, increased the real proportion of fish in its products to improve its score, proof that there was previously very little fish in the original recipe. Other groups, such as Danone, preferred simply to remove the logo from their packaging rather than modify their overly sweet drinking yoghurts.

Serge Hercberg is categorical about the economic argument: consumer association studies show that no price increase accompanied the implementation of the Nutri-Score, and well-rated products are no more expensive than their lower-rated competitors. For major groups with colossal turnover, the cost of reformulation remains derisory compared with advertising budgets. He also raises a reassuring point about sweeteners: the updated version of the algorithm now penalises drinks containing sweeteners such as aspartame, preventing manufacturers from simply replacing sugar with chemical substitutes to gain points.

The logo must extend to fresh produce

One practical limitation particularly worries Serge Hercberg: some consumers are turning away from fruit, vegetables and unlabelled fresh produce in favour of industrial products proudly displaying a Nutri-Score A or B. To correct that bias, extending the logo to packaged fresh produce such as meat and fish is currently being prepared administratively. For unpackaged products such as loose vegetables, the solution envisaged consists of displaying the score directly on the price labels on the shelf.

That extension comes with an essential reminder about how to use the logo: it is an alert signal, not a ban. Eating a product classified D or E does not cause immediate illness; it simply means you should not consume it too often or in too large a quantity, and that you should rebalance the rest of the meal or the day. The Nutri-Score was never intended to replace nutrition education, advertising regulation or behavioural taxation, but to add to those levers within a coherent public health approach.

Watch the full episode on YouTube

Taking action

The Nutri-Score remains an imperfect tool, but its limits are known, documented and largely corrected by additions such as the NOVA border. The real battle, according to Serge Hercberg, is no longer scientific but political: making the label compulsory to force the last industrial giants out of the shadows. Everyone can already use it intelligently, by comparing comparable products and keeping in mind that an unfavourable letter invites moderation rather than a ban.

These reference points belong to prevention and lifestyle, alongside medical follow-up and never in place of it. For an approach tailored to your situation, discover the Elite Longevity programmes. The details are explained during a first conversation.

Sources

Published work by Serge Hercberg

Scientific references on the topic

Going further

Frequently asked questions

Does the Nutri-Score take ultra-processed foods into account?

Not directly. The algorithm assesses only the nutritional composition, not the degree of industrial processing. Serge Hercberg proposes completing the label with a black border stating ultra-processed food according to the NOVA classification, because those two dimensions cannot be merged scientifically into a single algorithm.

Why is olive oil not classified A?

Olive oil is classified B, the best possible score for a pure fat. It does not get A because it remains made of a hundred per cent lipids, which limits recommended quantities, even though its nutritional quality is recognised as among the best in its category, on the same level as rapeseed oil.

Is the Nutri-Score compulsory in France?

No, it remains voluntary. More than fifteen hundred brands display it voluntarily, covering about sixty per cent of the market. A law is needed to make it compulsory, and a cross-party bill supported by around fifty MPs is currently under discussion in the French Parliament.

Why do some manufacturers refuse to display the Nutri-Score?

Some groups such as Danone removed the logo rather than reformulate their overly sweet products. Others, such as Coca-Cola, Mars or Lactalis, never adopted the label. Studies nevertheless show that consumers prefer a transparent brand, even a poorly rated one, to a brand that hides the information.

How do you compare products correctly using the Nutri-Score?

You have to compare foods consumed in a similar context: oils with each other, drinks with each other, breakfast cereals with each other. Comparing salmon with cereals makes no sense, since those products are never substitutable when making your food choices.

Does a bad Nutri-Score mean you should stop eating that product?

No. Serge Hercberg insists that the logo works as an alert signal, not as a ban. A product classified D or E can be consumed occasionally, in reasonable quantity, provided you rebalance the rest of the meal or the day with foods of better nutritional quality.

Latest from the blog

Read next